The article discusses the future of sports cars and whether they will still require manual transmissions. Michael Frank, a journalist, argues that with the advancement of technology, manual transmissions may no longer be necessary. He cites the example of the Audi RS3, which has a 7-speed automated manual gearbox, and claims that it is faster and more efficient than a manual transmission. He also mentions the Porsche 718 Boxster and Cayman, which have a 7-speed PDK dual-clutch automatic transmission, and argues that it is better suited for high-revving sports cars.
On the other hand, William Clavey, the editor-at-large, disagrees with Michael’s assessment. He believes that manual transmissions are still essential for sports cars, as they provide a more engaging and emotional driving experience. He cites the example of the BMW M3, which he drove with a manual transmission, and claims that it was more memorable and enjoyable than the automatic version.
The debate also touches on the topic of traffic and the future of electric vehicles (EVs). Michael argues that manual transmissions are not practical in heavy traffic, while William believes that driving a manual transmission in traffic is a challenge that requires more engagement and attention from the driver. They also discuss the Hyundai Ioniq 5 N, which has a simulated manual transmission, and agree that it provides a unique and entertaining driving experience.
Ultimately, both Michael and William agree that the future of sports cars is uncertain, but they both hope that manual transmissions will continue to exist in some form. They believe that EVs may be the key to saving manual transmissions, as they can be designed to simulate the experience of shifting gears. The article concludes that while manual transmissions may not be the most efficient or practical choice, they provide a unique emotional and engaging driving experience that is essential to the spirit of sports cars.
Key points:
* The debate centers around the question of whether manual transmissions are still necessary for sports cars.
* Michael Frank argues that automated manual gearboxes are faster and more efficient, while William Clavey believes that manual transmissions provide a more engaging driving experience.
* The discussion touches on the topics of traffic, electric vehicles, and the future of sports cars.
* Both authors agree that manual transmissions may not be the most practical choice, but they provide a unique emotional and engaging driving experience.
* The article concludes that EVs may be the key to saving manual transmissions, as they can be designed to simulate the experience of shifting gears.