The Mahindra BE 6 Pack Three and Hyundai Creta Electric Long Range Excellence are two electric SUVs that have been put to the test to see if their real-world range figures match their ARAI ranges. The BE 6 Pack Three has a larger 79kWh battery and a higher ARAI range of 683km, while the Creta Electric Long Range Excellence has a 51.4kWh battery and an ARAI range of 473km.
In terms of specifications, the BE 6 Pack Three has more power and torque than the Creta Electric Long Range Excellence, with 286hp and 380Nm compared to 171hp and 255Nm. The BE 6 also has a faster DC charging speed, with a 180kW charger compared to the Creta Electric’s 50kW charger. However, the Creta Electric is more efficient, with a real-world range of 432km compared to the BE 6’s 449km.
The Creta Electric’s smaller battery also means it takes less time to charge, with a full charge taking 4 hours and 50 minutes on an 11.2kW AC fast charger, compared to the BE 6’s 8 hours. The Creta Electric Long Range Excellence is also significantly cheaper than the BE 6 Pack Three, with a price difference of Rs 2.95 lakh.
In Autocar India’s range testing, the Creta Electric managed to go 486km in the city, 48km more than the BE 6, and had a battery efficiency of 8.4km/kWh, making it the second most efficient mass market EV tested. The BE 6 Pack Three’s combined range figure was 449km, which is 234km short of its ARAI range, and had a battery efficiency of 5.68km/kWh.
Overall, while the Mahindra BE 6 Pack Three has a larger battery and more power, the Hyundai Creta Electric Long Range Excellence is more efficient and has a longer real-world range. The Creta Electric’s smaller battery and lower price also make it a more attractive option for those looking for a more affordable electric SUV.
The testing procedure involved fully charging the battery, maintaining recommended tire pressures, and driving the car in a fixed loop in the city and on the highway. The climate control was set at 22 degrees Celsius, and other electricals such as the audio system and lights were used as needed. The range was calculated based on the percentage of charge consumed, and the results provide an accurate indication of what users can expect in the real world.
The results of the test show that the Creta Electric is a more efficient and practical option for those looking for an electric SUV, despite its smaller battery. The BE 6 Pack Three’s larger battery and more power do not necessarily translate to a longer real-world range, and its higher price makes it a less attractive option.